参与农业产业链对农户信贷配给的影响及机制研究

摘要基于陕西、山东两省1159户农户微观调研数据,在理论分析的基础上,通过Probit模型和中介效应模型,检验了农业产业链影响农户信贷配给的机制及效应。研究发现:参与农业产业链对农户供给型数量配给和需求型价格配给、风险配给及交易成本配给均有明显缓解作用;通过稳健性检验和工具变量法处理内生性问题后,结论依然成立。机制检验表明,参与农业产业链可以通过农业订单、担保措施和农业保险来提高农户抵押担保能力,缓解数量配给;通过增加农业收入、降低生产成本和提升产品质量来提高农户农业经营收益,缓解价格配给;通过减少生产风险、市场风险和自然风险来降低农户农业经营风险,缓解风险配给;通过减少贷款手续、审批时间和贷后检查来降低农户信贷交易成本,缓解交易成本配给。农业产业链对规模异质性农户的信贷配给影响存在差异:农业产业链对规模农户数量配给有显著负向影响,对小农户数量配给影响不显著,对小农户各类需求型信贷配给均有显著负向影响,对规模农户需求型信贷配给的缓解作用仅体现在交易成本配给上。因此,健全农业产业链利益联结和信息共享机制,完善信贷抵押担保功能,是新时期强化乡村振兴金融服务的重要战略选择。

	Service

	把本文推荐给朋友
	加入我的书架
	加入引用管理器
	Email Alert
	RSS
	作者相关文章
	赵囡
	王晶
	吕德宏

关键词：农业产业链农户信贷信息不对称供给型信贷配给需求型信贷配给

Abstract： Based on the micro survey data of 1159 farmers in Shaanxi and Shandong provinces, and on the basis of theoretical analysis, this paper tests the mechanism and effect of the agricultural industry chain on farmers 'credit rationing through Probit model and intermediary effect model. The study found that participating in the agricultural industry chain significantly alleviated farmers’ supply-based quantity rationing, demand-based price rationing, risk rationing and transaction cost rationing. After handling endogenous problems through robustness test and instrumental variable method, the conclusion is still valid. Mechanism test shows that participation in the agricultural industry chain can enhance farmers’ collateral capacity through agricultural orders, guarantee measures, and agricultural insurance, thereby alleviating quantitative rationing. It can increase farmers’ agricultural business income by increasing agricultural revenue, reducing production costs, and improving product quality, thus alleviating price rationing. It can reduce farmers’ agricultural business risks by decreasing production risks, market risks, and natural risks, thereby alleviating risk rationing. Furthermore, it can lower farmers’ credit transaction costs by reducing loan procedures, approval times, and post-loan inspections, thus alleviating transaction cost rationing. The impact of the agricultural industry chain on credit rationing for farmers of different scales shows variations: the agricultural industry chain has a significant negative effect on the quantitative rationing for large-scale farmers, while its impact on the quantitative rationing for small-scale farmers is not significant. It has a significant negative effect on various demand-oriented credit rationing for small-scale farmers, and its alleviating effect on demand-oriented credit rationing for large-scale farmers is only evident in transaction cost rationing. Therefore, strengthening the mechanisms for interest linkage and information sharing within the agricultural industry chain, and improving the functions of credit collateral and guarantees, are important strategic choices for enhancing rural revitalization financial services in the new era.

Keywords： Agricultural Chain Farmers’ Credit Information Asymmetry Supply-based Credit Rationing Demand-based Credit Rationing

收稿日期 2024-04-03; 接受日期 ;

基金资助:国家自然科学基金项目(72273106);陕西省软科学项目(2023CXRKX123)

作者简介: 赵囡(1990— ),女,河南洛阳人,博士研究生,主要从事农村金融研究;王晶(1994— ),女,甘肃正宁人,博士研究生,主要从事资源经济与环境管理研究;吕德宏(1969— ),男,陕西永寿人,博士,教授,主要从事农村金融理论与实践研究。吕德宏为本文通信作者。

引用本文:

赵囡, 王晶, 吕德宏.参与农业产业链对农户信贷配给的影响及机制研究[J]. 经济经纬, 2024,5: 65-76

ZHAO Nan, WANG Jing, LYU Dehong.A Study on the Impact and Mechanism of Participation in the Agricultural Industry Chain on the Credit Rationing of Farmers[J] Economic Survey, 2024,V41(5): 65-76

链接本文:

http://www.jjjw.org.cn/CN/ 或 http://www.jjjw.org.cn/CN/Y2024/V41/I5/65

陈超,徐磊,2020.流通型龙头企业主导下果品产业链的整合与培育:基于桃产业的理论与实践[J].农业经济问题(8):77-90.
程华,卢凤君,谢莉娇,2019.农业产业链组织的内涵、演化与发展方向[J].农业经济问题(12):118-128.
邓朝春,邢祖礼,2020.信贷配给、信息显示机制及对农村金融的启示[J].宏观经济研究(1):13-19.
董翀,钟真,孔祥智,2015.订单农业对农户的影响总是有效吗?——买方垄断和非垄断市场订单农业参与效果的对比研究[J].商业经济与管理 (4):16-23.
顾庆康,林乐芬,2021.不同农地抵押贷款机制下农户信贷配给分析[J].农业经济问题(7):67-77.
郭熙保,吴方,2022.合同农业能否有效提高家庭农场技术效率和收入:基于812个种植业家庭农场调查数据的倾向得分匹配分析[J].农业技术经济(12):23-42.
韩江波,2018.“环-链-层”:农业产业链运作模式及其价值集成治理创新[J].经济学家(10):97-104.
何广文,何婧,郭沛,2018.再议农户信贷需求及其信贷可得性[J].农业经济问题(2):38-49.
黄颖,吕德宏,张珩,2021.政策性农业保险对农户贫困脆弱性的影响研究:以地方特色农产品保险为例[J].保险研究(5):16-32.
姜松,2018.农业价值链金融创新的现实困境与化解之策:以重庆为例[J].农业经济问题(9):44-54.
蒋逸,马九杰,2014.产业组织形态、商业信用与农户融资困境的缓解:基于四川省生猪产业的三个典型案例[J].东岳论丛(1):159-167.
李莉,黄和亮,黄森慰,等,2023.林权抵押贷款信贷配给的影响因素及其异质性分析:基于福建省农户调研数据的研究[J].经济与管理研究(4):71-89.
李庆海,吕小锋,孙光林,2016.农户信贷配给:需求型还是供给型?——基于双重样本选择模型的分析[J].中国农村经济(1):17-29.
梁虎,罗剑朝,2019.供给型和需求型信贷配给及影响因素研究:基于农地抵押背景下4省3459户数据的经验考察[J].经济与管理研究(1):29-40.
刘森挥,曹建民,张越杰,2019.农户组织模式与其技术效率的关系:一个考虑样本异质性的分析[J].农业技术经济(12):68-79.
刘西川,程恩江,2009.贫困地区农户的正规信贷约束:基于配给机制的经验考察[J].中国农村经济(6):37-50.
刘西川,程恩江,2013.中国农业产业链融资模式:典型案例与理论含义[J].财贸经济(8):47-57.
刘馨月,周力,2020.订单农业契约属性安排:农户风险态度与契约选择决策[J].南京农业大学学报(社会科学版)(2):140-148.
刘祚祥,黄权国,2012.信息生产能力、农业保险与农村金融市场的信贷配给:基于修正的S-W模型的实证分析[J].中国农村经济(5):53-64.
彭澎,吕开宇,2017.农户正规信贷交易成本配给识别及其影响因素:来自浙江省和黑龙江省466户农户调查数据的分析[J].财贸研究(3):39-49.
彭澎,吴承尧,肖斌卿,2018.银保互联对中国农村正规信贷配给的影响:基于4省1014户农户调查数据的分析[J].中国农村经济(8):32-45.
王力恒,何广文,何婧,2016.农业供应链外部融资的发展条件:基于信息经济学的数理分析[J].中南大学学报(社会科学版)(4):79-85.
温忠麟,叶宝娟,2014.中介效应分析:方法和模型发展[J].心理科学进展(5):731-745.
吴比,刘俊杰,徐雪高,等,2016.农户组织化对农民技术采用的影响研究:基于11省1022个农户调查数据的实证分析[J].农业技术经济 (8):25-33.
吴本健,罗兴,马九杰,2018.农业价值链融资的演进:贸易信贷与银行信贷的替代、互补与互动[J].农业经济问题(2):78-86.
尹鸿飞,2020.农地确权能否缓解农村正规信贷配给?——基于德·索托效应的再检验[J].华中农业大学学报(社会科学版)(3):158-167,176.
虞锡君,2005.农业保险与农业产业化互动机制探析[J].农业经济问题(8):54-56,80.
赵德余,吴陈孜薇,2022.我国东西部协作型农业产业扶贫政策网络特征及其效果分析[J].贵州大学学报(社会科学版) (5):32-42.
郑志浩,高杨,霍学喜,2024.农户经营规模与土地生产率关系的再探究:来自第三次全国农业普查规模农户的证据[J].管理世界(1):89-108.
周月书,王雨露,彭媛媛,2019.农业产业链组织、信贷交易成本与规模农户信贷可得性[J].中国农村经济(4):41-54.
祝国平,郭连强,李新光,2022.农户产业链参与对信贷获得的影响[J].经济与管理研究(4):82-95.
邹建国,李明贤,2019.农业供应链金融视角的农户信用增进研究[J].财经理论与实践(6):32-38.
BEYHAGHI M,FIROOZI F,JALILVAND A,et al,2020.Components of credit rationing[J].Journal of financial stability,50:1-16.
BOUCHER S R,CARTER M R,GUIRKINGER C,2008.Risk rationing and wealth effects in credit markets:theory and implications for agricultural development[J].American journal of agricultural economics,90(2):409-423.
BOUCHER S R,GUIRKINGER C,TRIVELLI C,2009.Direct elicitation of credit constraints:conceptual and practical issues with an application to Peruvian agriculture[J].Economic development and cultural change,57(4):609 -640.
GUIRKINGER C,BOUCHER S R,2008.Credit constraints and productivity in Peruvian agriculture[J].Agricultural economics,39(3):295-308.
KHANDKER S R,KOOLWAL G B,2016.How has microcredit supported agriculture? Evidence using panel data from Bangladesh[J].Agricultural economics,47(2):157-168.
SHRESTHA R B,HUANG W C,GAUTAM S,et al,2016.Efficiency of small scale vegetable farms:policy implications for the rural poverty reduction in Nepal[J].Agricultural economics,62(4):181-195.
STIGLITZ J E,WEISS A,1981.Credit rationing in markets with imperfect information[J].The American economic review,71(3):393-410.